Analysis
Talks between London and Brussels on aligning UK food rules with those of the European Union have moved towards the centre of UK politics. The island is not a party to those talks, but because it shares a customs area with the UK, the outcome is worth watching closely here.
What has been reported
According to BBC News on 15 November, the UK would have a “voice” but no vote on EU food rules under the proposed “Brexit reset”. The BBC reported that Hamish Falconer, the UK’s EU minister, maintained that Britain would keep some influence over policy under a new deal.
Two days earlier, the BBC reported the prime minister, Andy Burnham, as saying a “win-win” agreement could be reached. He said it could be “more like the Brexit people thought they were voting for” in 2016.
The technical terms of any agreement have not yet been published. Those terms will decide what a change would mean in practice.
Separately, HM Treasury has published a joint statement with the European Commission on the sixth EU-UK Financial Regulatory Forum, held in November.
Why the island is in the frame
The Isle of Man and the UK operate a customs union, so changes to UK border and goods arrangements are of direct interest here. How any UK-EU food standards deal would apply to the island is not yet clear. Nor is it clear how the Manx government would be consulted on it.
That raises a familiar question for the island. If the UK itself would have a voice but no vote on EU food rules, any Manx influence would come further down the line, through London.
Households and the cost of living
Island inflation stood at 4.8% in October, according to Manx Wire’s economic reporting. In September the Manx rate was 4.1%, against 3.5% in the UK. The island’s rate was higher than the UK’s in every month from May to September. Bank Rate is 4%.
Whether easier food trade between the UK and the EU would feed through to prices on Manx shelves is uncertain. Any effect would depend on what is agreed and when it takes effect.
Freight and the Irish Sea
Sea crossings are a separate cost. In the House of Keys, Ayre and Michael MHK Stephen Broad argued that the cost of crossing the Irish Sea puts Manx firms at a disadvantage. In reply he heard that the Treasury keeps Steam Packet fuel prices and surcharges under watch and will continue to review the issue.
A UK-EU food agreement would not, on its own, change those crossing charges.
Public finances
Customs and excise duties collected in the island and the UK are shared under the Common Purse arrangement, using an agreed formula. Changes to the UK’s tariff or border regime could therefore affect Manx revenue in either direction. Any such effect would depend on trade volumes and tariff treatment, which have not been set out.
HM Treasury also publishes guidance on temporary duty suspensions and autonomous tariff quotas for goods imported into the UK. This is a reminder that tariff settings are a live area of UK policy.
The island’s income and corporate tax regime is set by Tynwald and is not part of the UK-EU discussions.
Finance sector
The EU-UK Financial Regulatory Forum concerns the UK’s relationship with the EU on financial services. The island is outside the EU, and the forum does not in itself change the island’s position. Any knock-on effect for Manx firms would be indirect.
Housing
For many households, other pressures loom larger. Housing Minister Rob Callister told Manx Radio he was “shocked” that no homes were available for first-time buyers. He said he hopes to make changes as soon as he can.
What to watch
The open questions are whether a deal is concluded, when any alignment would begin, and how the Manx government would be consulted on rules that may affect the island. Until the terms are published, the effects discussed here remain possibilities rather than forecasts.


Comments: read or add yours
Have your say
0 comments · Community guidelines
No comments yet. Start the cooish.