Treasury Minister Michael Crowe has said it is hard to justify specific support for heating oil customers, after an MHK warned that some island families are choosing between heating, cooking and lighting their homes.
Ayre and Michael MHK Stephen Broad raised the issue during Tuesday’s sitting of the House of Keys, the elected chamber of Tynwald, according to Isle of Man Today and Energy FM. He had tabled a question asking what Treasury had done to ease the effect of rising heating fuel costs.
Mr Broad told the House: “In my constituency there are families that are having to choose between turning the lights on, cooking a meal or heating their homes.” He said the island was “getting dangerously close to a Dickensian novel for some families” and asked whether the minister could offer “some real assistance this winter”.
Mr Crowe said the picture described was one “none of us in this House would like to see”. He pointed to support available across government, including through his own Social Security brief, for people in greatest need.
The minister said Treasury had monitored fuel costs for several years, and that this had intensified since the conflict in the Middle East. He said disruption to energy supplies had pushed up retail heating oil prices on the island, which are regularly revised as new shipments come in.
By contrast, electricity and natural gas prices had not reflected large wholesale increases because of forward purchasing, Mr Crowe said, as reported by Energy FM.
He told members that September figures put heating oil at between 11.26p and 11.7p per kWh. Natural gas stood at 12.05p and standard direct electricity heating at 33.42p.
Mr Crowe said fairness and proportionality should guide policy on energy shocks. He said it was “challenging to justify support for heating oil customers when prices are comparable or lower” than those users of other fuels had paid for many years.
He highlighted the Heat Wise Home Scheme, which he said is due to begin in the next couple of months. According to Energy FM, it will offer grants and loans to eligible households for air source heat pumps and other energy efficiency work.
He also said heating oil prices had fallen this week, and he hoped residents would see some benefit.
Mr Broad asked whether the minister would agree to a winter fuel payment for vulnerable and low-paid households on supplementary benefits and pensions. Energy FM reported Mr Crowe as saying that such a payment for people struggling on benefits was something government could consider.
He said a strategic co-ordination group of senior officers had been set up to monitor fuel prices and other risks. “We will certainly monitor the situation and should it become necessary, yes, I am sure government would respond,” he said.
Glenfaba and Peel MHK Katryna Baptist called for a review of benefit rates and eligibility thresholds. Mr Crowe said rates and criteria would be reviewed as part of the process ahead of the February Budget, according to Energy FM.


Comments: read or add yours
Have your say
0 comments · Community guidelines
No comments yet. Start the cooish.