An internal review has concluded that the Department of Infrastructure held information about the proposed Mooir Vannin wind farm that it had told campaigners it did not have, Energy FM reported on its manx.news site on 15 November.
The Freedom of Information request (reference 5333242) was made in February by the campaign group NOT4IOM. It sought details of the 2015 Agreement for Lease, and of later changes to it, setting out Ørsted’s rights over Manx territorial waters.
According to Energy FM, the department turned down major parts of the request in April on grounds of commercial sensitivity, and said the rest of the information was not held.
The internal review reached a different view. It found that the information requested was held by the department and that the search for it had not been reasonable. The outlet reported that two key divisions had never been asked to look for records. Third parties had not been consulted before the commercial sensitivity exemptions were relied on. The department was also faulted for not offering reasonable advice and assistance.
Further searches identified an estimated 25 to 30 boxes of records relating to Ørsted held in storage, as well as electronic records, none of which had been accounted for when the request was first handled, Energy FM said.
The review told the department to begin the process again. That means new searches, consultation with the relevant parties and a fresh assessment of the public interest.
Energy FM reported that, almost nine months on from the original request, nothing has been released and no date for publication has been given.
NOT4IOM also wants to know whether any of the stored material was taken into account during the examination of Mooir Vannin under the Marine Infrastructure Management Act, the process for assessing major offshore schemes, which ended in September. The group says it is not clear whether the records played a part in the department’s submissions to that examination.
Georgina O’Sullivan, for NOT4IOM, accused the department of delaying, refusing and disputing that information existed when it was later shown that it did.
The group believes the non-confidential sections of the lease agreement should be made public before ministers reach a final decision on the wind farm. It is asking the Infrastructure Minister, Jason Moorhouse MHK, to step in, set a firm date for disclosure and make sure the review’s recommendations are carried out in full. It has said it may take the matter to the Information Commissioner if there are further delays.


Comments: read or add yours
Have your say
0 comments · Community guidelines
No comments yet. Start the cooish.